Customer Reviews for All Tire & Service

"Chris, I believe is the owner, is incredibly trustworthy and knowledgeable in all that is car. I had a tire repaired there a few months ago, he didn't push for me to get all 4 replace, as many do. Recently I got an oil low message and being a female, won't go there...will end up putting it into coolant space or something--destroy the whole engine. I just have no car clue. He had the oil added and tire air pressure adjusted and didn't want to charge anything. I was pretty surprised, as a woman, you know what I mean. We are almost always taken in mechanics shops, which is unfortunate. Chris is honest and I would encourage all women to definitely feel confident bringing their car to his shop without worrying that he is going to create unnecessary work that doesn't need to get done. He is also a cat person, that is a big PLUS with me. I did tip the worker who took care of the issues, though. He is at a perfect location, as well. Thank you Chris, will hopefully not see you soon, unless I need to!!"

Mersada Cobovic

"Chris and all the workers are experienced, timely, and professional. Most importantly, I trust them when they give me an estimate. I know that that is work that my car needs. They also tell me what might be needed down the road what things I can wait on and what things are urgent."

Jennifer Smith

"We want to thank you for your help this morning! Our daughter Savannah attends Wagner College, while on the road this morning she heard a rumbling and pulled into the Dunkin Donuts, she discovered a flat tire caused by a huge screw. While we were in Jersey, all we could do was ask her what was around her. We noticed your shop very close to where she was, she took a walk over to ask for help; this was 8:35 AM. The gentleman on duty assisted her so quickly and was very helpful, caring and kind. The tire was replaced and she headed back to school for her scheduled class, though she was a little late she was back on campus by 10:00 AM! It’s hard to send your kids off to college, especially out of state and away from home. We are so grateful and will spread the word around Wagner Campus about how helpful, professional and reliable you were! Thank You! Jason & Tricia Czornomor"

Tricia Czornomor

"Many many years customer service has always been exceptional.. highly recommend… knowledge.. attention to mechanical detail.. top notch mechanics.."

Frank Fazio

"Staff here is very friendly and genuine. They do a great job too, I would highly recommend them! Went in with a flat, they were able to patch it and saved me a bunch of time and money!"

J M

"This shop does excellent work. Had new tires installed on my Rivian as well as an alignment. Tricky vehicle to lift as are all EVs, but no issues at All Tire. Have been taking my cars (both ICE and EV) here for years and they've never disappointed."

Joseph Eschbach

"Had no appointment but the team was able to take care of my blowout within the hour. It's my second time using this shop and would definitely recommend others to do so."

angel suarez

"All Tire was excellent from start to finish. They set an appointment for me and honored it. Did the work I needed with very short shop time. And seemed fairly reasonably priced (I haven’t had to get brakes redone recently so I’m not totally sure about competitive rates for my rear brake service."

Gordon Wurmstich

"I have been going to All Tire for literally decades and they are the best automotive service in the area by far. They are very honest, knowledgeable, reputable and you can trust them to do the job once and do it right. If you need service on your vehicle give them a call you will not be disappointed."

Salvatore Rannazzisi

"Great service - fast, professional, and most of all: trustworthy. 1 My car had an intermittent issue that would have required hours of expensive diagnostic assessment at a different car shop. (That other car shop charged $189/hr and refused to give even a ballpark estimate for the *range* of hours it might take. It could have been 2 or 10 hours. They didn't know.) 2 But I brought my car to All Tire and my car was in and out in 2 days for a fee that was transparent and made sense. Car runs great! 3 All Tire & Service has been around for over 20 years - and I can see why they have such a *consistent* stellar rating. Definitely recommend. 💫🏆 PS - *I came to All Tire because the front office rep at that other car shop got weirdly hostile and upset when I asked for details on their hourly rate ($189/hr) and a ballpark estimate of the number of hours to do the diagnostic on my car. She seemed personally offended by my question and became combative... *But I'm only available for kind, respectful, and professional treatment. So I came to All Tire. And that's what I got. 🌺 Breath of fresh air. Thanks All Tire!"

Nkiruka N

"Everything was perfect as always — fast, smooth, and professional. The team provided clear recommendations and explanations, which I really appreciate. A special thank you to Rob for reminding me about my upcoming visit so I wouldn’t miss my state inspection. Outstanding service every time!"

Larysa Nesterovych

"I had a flat tire and stopped by All Tire & Service to get it replaced. From start to finish, the service was outstanding. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and quick — they diagnosed the issue right away and had me back on the road in less than 24 hours. They even checked my other tires to make sure everything was safe before I left. It’s rare to find this level of professionalism and honesty these days. I’ll definitely be returning and recommending them to friends and family!"

Alexandra C.

"I wish I could give 10 stars. I am from out of state and am working in the area and driving a rental. I drove from Manhattan to a couple stops in Staten Island this AM with a low tire light. It was cold this AM and I just figured the pressure would adjust itself. After my second stop it never did and I was sitting at a traffic light and this shop was literally across the street. I pulled in an asked if they could check the tire and give me some air. Turns out I had a big slice out of my tire!!!! Vinny was SO kind and they had the tire in stock. By the grace of god, I found this shop and when I called National Roadside assistance and my employer, everyone was in agreement that I should just replace the tire. Vinny and his crew had me in and out in 20 minutes, at a fair price, they did not gouge an out of towner, and I did not miss a single beat the rest of the day. These guys probably literally saved my life. I am newer to parking and driving in the city and this could have been a disaster. If I lived locally, I would be a very loyal customer to this place and I cannot recommend or thank them enough!"

Sarah M

"I ended up here by accident after I had a tire blowout on the bridge and needed to be towed. I was on my way to a charity event and had two dogs in the car, so I was pretty stressed, but these guys were great! They got my tire replaced quickly, the price was reasonable and they didn’t try to hard sell me other stuff that I didn’t need. They also were genuinely nice and went above and beyond to make the situation less stressful. If they were closer they would definitely be my new regular place. I’m hoping never to end up stranded on a bridge again, but if I was, these guys would be my first call. If you live locally, check them out!"

Janice Costa

"I have been in this all tire location a couple times, I have done 2 oil change, all 4 tire replacement, coolant replacement, link and bushes here. All done in 1 day, and professional. The price is reasonable too. I'm looking forward to do more maintenance here."

Noober21

"Great experience. Paul was great on the phone before we even went over. He was so helpful, got the car there and they right away went to check out the problem. Gave me choices on tires and was able to fix everything I needed at one place. They told me what work I still need to get done for the future with approximate cost . Would recommended 100%."

Sam Casco

"Thank you, Nick, for your outstanding service and professionalism. I really appreciate the care and attention you put into getting my tires taken care of. Your help made the whole experience quick and stress-free—thank you!"

Pat Ruggiero

"Best experience you can possibly have. Realized I got a flat when I got to work in the morning. I live in jersey so I was worried how I would get home at night. I couldnt leave my job but escaped for a few mins, brought them the car they fixed the tire in less than 20 mins and I was out. Saved my day. And it was only 30 bucks."

Waqar Yussouf

"Service was quick and efficient. Andrew was a very good representative for the company. He explained to me the details of what was going on with my tire and found a replacement immediately. I'm satisfied with this auto shop."

Karen Leonard

"Nick told me to come right up after I called and asked if they could put a new battery in my Honda Odessey. And Gary installed the new battery after waiting a while for new battery hold downs. Both men were very accommodating and knowledgeable. Thank You All Tire."

Robert Taverna

"My tire popped on Saturday afternoon. It was our families only way of transportation for that week they got me in early next morning no problem and had new tires within a couple hours. Thank you so much!"

Daniella Bertonazzi

"I brought my car in after the check engine light came on, and I couldn't be happier with the service I received. The team was professional, friendly, and most importantly, took the time to explain everything in simple, easy-to-understand terms. I never felt rushed or talked down to, and I left feeling confident about the work that was done. Highly recommend to anyone looking for honest and reliable car service!"

Judy Barnes

"I always like coming here for my car servicing needs. They are quick to detect any issues and don't pressure you to repair anything that can wait a little longer. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Would definitely recommend!"

Calvin F

"I’ve been coming to All Tire & Service on Page Ave for years — even back when it was Jojo’s — and it just keeps getting better. I’ve had everything done here from oil changes to flat tire repairs and inspections. The service is always quick, honest, and convenient. Kevin is a great guy who really takes care of his customers. Highly recommend this place!"

Marc Dolce

"Kevin and his team at All Tires & Service are top-notch! From the moment I pulled in, I was greeted with honesty, professionalism, and real expertise. Kevin takes the time to explain everything clearly and makes sure you’re comfortable with the work being done. The service is fast, fair-priced, and you can tell they truly care about their customers. It’s rare to find a shop you can fully trust, but Kevin has definitely earned my loyalty. Highly recommend All Tires & Service to anyone looking for quality work and great customer service!"

Bruce Daniele

"I stopped by to get a quick inspection done on my Honda pilot. They were happy to take care of me without an appointment. They did it quickly honestly and I couldn’t be happier. And this day and age is so hard to find mechanic shops where you feel comfortable And can trust that they’re being honest this is one of them."

Keith Hegdal

"Spoke to Kevin via Email the day before. arrived met Kevin he verified what tires I wanted. During installation he came and showed the alignment results asked if I wanted alignment yes or no. with no hard sell. They noticed inspection was due and offered to do it then. They had me in and out pretty quick. Definitely will use them again"

Carlos Sotomayor

"Been here a couple of times. Great work and prices, fast, professional and honest service. They take care of their customers. Always a pleasant experience. I recommend them to everyone I know. Thanks so much!"

Jenny Sarian